So, your Big Green Egg thermometer is acting weird? Maybe it’s stuck on 200°F even when your grill is cold, or it’s slow to change when things heat up. Don’t worry you’re not alone, and fixing it is easier than you might think. Here’s a step-by-step guide that walks you through what to check, how to calibrate, and when it might be time for a fresh start.
1. Check the Basics First
Sometimes, the issue is simple. Make sure the thermometer is mounted snugly on the lid, and nothing is blocking it. If it’s loose or tilted, that alone can mess with the reading.
2. Try a Boiling Water Test
Remove the thermometer and dip the probe in a pot of boiling water. Water boils at 212°F (or 100°C) at sea level, so that’s your target. Be careful not to let the probe touch the bottom of the pot—it can give a false reading.
3. Adjust It Manually
If the needle doesn’t point to 212°F, you can tweak it. On the back of the thermometer, there’s a small nut. Use a wrench to gently turn it until the needle lines up with boiling point. That’s how you “recalibrate” it. Think of it like tuning a guitar string—it needs the right tension to play in tune.
4. Test with Ice Water Too
For peace of mind, you can also dip the probe in ice water. It should hit close to 32°F (0°C). If it doesn’t drop low enough, the needle might be sticking, or the internal part may be faulty.
5. Look for Physical Damage
Is the glass cracked? Is the dial foggy or discolored? Does the needle feel jammed? If yes, it’s probably time to replace the thermometer. Just like a compass that can’t point north, a grill thermometer that’s off lost its purpose.
6. Check for Airflow Issues
Believe it or not, poor airflow in your Egg can make the temps feel off, even if the thermometer works fine. Clear out any ash, double-check your vents, and make sure the firebox is clean.
7. Know When It’s Time to Replace
If you’ve tried everything and it still doesn’t read right—especially during actual cooks—it’s time to move on. Many Egg owners, including myself, have switched to third-party thermometers like those from Tel-Tru. They’re reliable, affordable, and often more accurate than the stock ones.
Final Thoughts
Big Green Egg thermometers aren’t perfect, but the brand itself is known for durability and thoughtful design. Like any tool, things can go off over time—but most issues are fixable with a little patience. And if not, there are great replacements out there that keep the Egg experience as legendary as ever.
Fixing a wonky thermometer may feel like chasing smoke at first, but once it clicks, you’ll wonder why you didn’t check it sooner. Happy grilling!
Related articles